# 2016 demonstration design — published-input audit; ideal-gas approximation

Model 1.0.0. No reactor-performance or safety validation.

## Exact request

```json
{
  "kind": "reference",
  "basis": "design-2016"
}
```

## Published inputs

```json
{
  "id": "design-2016",
  "label": "2016 demonstration design",
  "sourceId": "S1",
  "locator": "Section 2, Figure 2, Table 1; abstract",
  "values": {
    "moduleCount": 2,
    "thermalPowerMW": 250,
    "heliumInletC": 250,
    "heliumOutletC": 750,
    "heliumPressureMPa": 7,
    "heliumFlowKgS": null,
    "steamPressureMPa": 13.25,
    "steamTemperatureC": 567,
    "feedwaterTemperatureC": null,
    "feedwaterFlowKgS": null,
    "electricalRatingMW": 210
  },
  "note": "Primary concept identity. Helium flow and feedwater values are deliberately unpopulated in this transcription; S2 is not silently substituted."
}
```

## Property and inventory inputs

```json
{
  "propertyModel": {
    "sourceId": "S5",
    "molarMassKgMol": 0.004002602,
    "minK": 298,
    "maxK": 6000,
    "coefficients": {
      "A": 20.78603,
      "B": 4.850638e-10,
      "C": -1.582916e-10,
      "D": 1.525102e-11,
      "E": 3.196347e-11,
      "F": -6.197341,
      "H": 0
    }
  },
  "inventoryInputs": {
    "coreDiameterM": 3,
    "meanCoreHeightM": 11,
    "pebbleDiameterM": 0.06,
    "fuelZoneDiameterM": 0.05,
    "pebbleCount": 420000,
    "sourceIds": [
      "S1",
      "S2",
      "S3"
    ],
    "locator": "S1 Table 1 / S2 Section 2: mean cylinder and approximate inventory; S3 p.1: pebble and fuel-zone diameters. Cross-source geometric audit.",
    "note": "Equivalent cylinder using mean height, not the actual tapered bed. Uniform non-overlapping spheres; counts and mean height are approximate. Computed void fraction is an aggregate ratio, not a packing solution."
  },
  "scenarioDefinition": {
    "basisId": "study-2017",
    "defaults": {
      "thermalPowerMW": 250,
      "heliumFlowKgS": 96,
      "heliumInletC": 250
    },
    "bounds": {
      "thermalPowerMW": {
        "min": 25,
        "max": 300,
        "step": 1,
        "unit": "MW",
        "label": "Heat transferred to helium"
      },
      "heliumFlowKgS": {
        "min": 20,
        "max": 140,
        "step": 0.1,
        "unit": "kg/s",
        "label": "Helium mass flow"
      },
      "heliumInletC": {
        "min": 50,
        "max": 400,
        "step": 1,
        "unit": "°C",
        "label": "Helium inlet temperature"
      }
    },
    "flowFactors": [
      0.8,
      0.85,
      0.9,
      0.95,
      1,
      1.05,
      1.1,
      1.15,
      1.2
    ],
    "note": "These are software exploration bounds, not licensed operating limits. All applied heat enters one perfectly mixed helium stream. No heat storage, bypass, leakage, blower work or external loss."
  },
  "numericalMethod": {
    "outlet": "monotone bisection",
    "iterations": 64,
    "propertyRangeK": [
      298,
      6000
    ],
    "receipt": "deterministic; timestamps belong to execution metadata, not this result"
  }
}
```

## Results

| Quantity | Value | Unit | Evidence |
|---|---:|---|---|
| Heat carried at published temperatures and flow | Not populated | MW/module | derived ideal-gas estimate; S1; S5 |
| Carried heat minus published power | Not populated | MW/module | derived difference; not a safety margin; S1; S5 |
| Difference relative to published power | Not populated | % | derived difference; not uncertainty; S1; S5 |
| Flow required for published power and temperatures | 96.28105992182346 | kg/s/module | derived, not a published flow; S1; S5 |
| Helium enthalpy rise | 2596.5646847156695 | kJ/kg | ideal-gas property relation; S5 |
| Mean model heat capacity | 5.193129369431339 | kJ/(kg K) | derived from enthalpy rise; S5 |
| Heat capacity required for exact table closure | Not populated | kJ/(kg K) | inferred from published power, temperatures and flow; S1 |
| Two-module thermal rating | 500 | MW | derived sum of published ratings; S1 |
| Electrical / thermal rating ratio | 0.42 | fraction | rating ratio; not a modeled net efficiency; S1 |
| Required secondary enthalpy gain at full heat transfer | Not populated | kJ/kg | heat-balance demand; not steam-property output; S1 |
| Hot-end helium minus steam temperature | 183 | K | difference of published endpoints; not local pinch; S1 |
| Cold-end helium minus feedwater temperature | Not populated | K | difference of published endpoints; not local pinch; S1 |
| Equivalent cylindrical core volume | 77.75441817634739 | m³ | derived from mean height and diameter; S1; S2 |
| Aggregate sphere volume | 47.500880922277666 | m³ | approximate inventory × sphere volume; S1; S2; S3 |
| Aggregate solid volume fraction | 0.6109090909090907 | fraction | geometric ratio; not discrete packing; S1; S2; S3 |
| Aggregate void volume fraction | 0.38909090909090926 | fraction | geometric ratio; not local porosity; S1; S2; S3 |
| Mean volumetric power at published rating | 3.215251375593845 | MW/m³ | average; no spatial distribution; S1 |
| Mean heat per pebble at published rating | 595.2380952380952 | W/pebble | average; not maximum or fuel temperature; S1 |
| Fuel-bearing zone / pebble volume | 0.5787037037037038 | fraction | geometric ratio; not fuel material fraction; S3 |
| Fuel-free graphite shell thickness | 0.0049999999999999975 | m | half the difference in diameters; S3 |

## Sensitivity

| Flow (kg/s) | Mixed outlet (°C) | Classification |
|---:|---:|---|


## Equations

- t = (T°C + 273.15) / 1000; h(T) = [A t + B t²/2 + C t³/3 + D t⁴/4 − E/t + F − H] / M. h in kJ/kg; M in kg/mol; coefficients return kJ/mol. S5.
- QHe = ṁ × [h(Tout) − h(Tin)] / 1000; residual = QHe − Qpublished. Q in MW; ṁ in kg/s. S1, S2, S5.
- ṁrequired = 1000 Qpublished / Δh; h(Tout,scenario) = h(Tin) + 1000 Qscenario / ṁscenario. ṁ in kg/s; Tout by bounded bisection. S5.
- Vcore = π D² H / 4; Vpebble = π d³ / 6; solid fraction = N Vpebble / Vcore; void fraction = 1 − solid fraction. Lengths in metres; volumes in m³; fractions dimensionless. S1, S2, S3.
- q̄core = Qpublished / Vcore; P̄pebble = 10⁶ Qpublished / N; fuel-zone volume fraction = (dfuel / dpebble)³. MW/m³; W/pebble; dimensionless fraction. S1, S2, S3.

## Limitations

- Steady-state bookkeeping, not a reactor simulation or a prediction of operating behavior.
- Standard-state ideal-gas helium enthalpy; pressure effects at the published 7 MPa are not evaluated. No quantified model uncertainty is supplied.
- All applied heat enters one mixed helium stream. Bypass flow, spatial power shape, losses, heat storage, circulator work and pressure drop are omitted.
- No water/steam equation of state is implemented. Secondary enthalpy demand and endpoint temperature differences are algebraic annotations, not exchanger sizing or steam-performance predictions.
- Inventory uses an equivalent cylinder and approximate sphere count. Average heat per pebble is not a peak, particle temperature, packing result or fuel-performance limit.
- Sensitivity curves vary one input at a time within software bounds. They are neither uncertainty intervals nor safe operating envelopes.
- Display geometry is independent of these inputs and remains illustrative; no numerical field is painted onto the 3D model.
- No neutronics, reactivity, transient, decay-heat, accident, safety, licensing or manufacturing conclusion follows from these calculations.

## Sources

- S1: [Zhang et al. (2016) · HTR-PM demonstration power plant](https://www.engineering.org.cn/engi/EN/10.1016/J.ENG.2016.01.020). Section 2, Figure 2, Table 1; steam-generator subsection. Accessed 2026-11-07. Historical design basis, not current operation or dimensional manufacturing drawings. HTML read; PDF redirect failed.
- S2: [Wang, Shi & Zheng (2017) · HTR-PM steam-generator study](https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1155/2017/8521410). Section 2, Figures 1–2, Table 1. Accessed 2026-11-07. A separate 2017 study basis, not a correction to S1. Only steady-state reference values are used; no precooling or accident results are reproduced.
- S3: [Yang, Liu & Tang (2014) · HTR-PM fuel element](https://nucleus.iaea.org/sites/htgr-kb/HTR2014/Paper%20list/Track3/HTR2014-31281.pdf). HTR2014-31281, page 1, abstract and introduction. Accessed 2026-11-06. Particle positions in this concept are authored; no temperature/stress or failure-probability results are reproduced.
- S5: [NIST Chemistry WebBook, SRD 69 · Helium](https://webbook.nist.gov/cgi/cbook.cgi?Name=helium&cTG=on). Gas Phase Heat Capacity (Shomate Equation), 298–6000 K; molecular weight. Accessed 2026-11-07. Used as an ideal-gas approximation. No density or pressure-dependent departure function; no uncertainty bound for 7 MPa helium. Data attributed to Chase (1998), reviewed March 1982.
- S6: [Ortiz Vega et al. (2023) · NIST IR 8474, helium equation of state](https://www.nist.gov/publications/equation-state-thermodynamic-properties-helium). Abstract; DOI 10.6028/NIST.IR.8474. Accessed 2026-11-07. Abstract read. Equation and REFPROP implementation are not used here. No claim of agreement with that model.

## Fingerprints

```json
{
  "algorithm": "sha256",
  "definition": "3379679e3204ac07b0b68b94de7cc489725c8621395091bd7821f3c65004a24e",
  "model": "c5ff39b7d16b0d305fcf04426dd3f682e9db09719d0244570c080792771ae726",
  "state": "4263cc664eff25ce1b56c87450ee1dd35f886f892531ff88290d3f8af91b4dc2",
  "presentation": "88eadebb31f1a758c097e1e69cac82a6e5c005999ed6465d07bfdaa25fc81099",
  "sourcePacket": "6d0deba49c8a20418705b2cbc2e92c2c00ac4eaa8b0de003d9752c9ff21cdab7"
}
```

Reproduce with the adjacent JSON receipt and `npm run htgr:analysis -- --replay path/to/receipt.json --out /tmp/htr-pm-replay`. JSON carries exact published inputs and all numerical values.
